In a significant legal victory, the California Sportfishing Protection Alliance (CSPA) secured funding from WHEN Justice to support a lawsuit against AT&T regarding lead contamination in Lake Tahoe. This funding, amounting to $100,000, was pivotal in linking lead from abandoned cables to environmental pollution, ultimately leading to a swift settlement in 2023.
Strategic Funding Transforms Environmental Litigation
The lawsuit against AT&T stemmed from the presence of toxic lead cables, which had been degrading in Lake Tahoe for decades. These cables, originally installed as early telecommunications lines, contained over 100,000 pounds of lead. The CSPA filed a lawsuit in 2021 to compel AT&T to remove the hazardous materials. However, the case faced challenges due to the high costs associated with scientific testing and evidence gathering.
The turning point came when Roland Peralta, founder of WHEN Justice, stepped in with a commitment to fund necessary scientific research. “That was the ‘aha’ moment, where we realized we could scale this model,” Peralta stated. This funding facilitated crucial sampling and isotopic testing, which provided the evidence needed to prove that the lead was leaching into the lake’s waters.
Overcoming Financial Barriers in Environmental Justice
WHEN Justice's model addresses a critical gap in environmental litigation funding. Many smaller organizations struggle to finance the scientific testing essential for their cases. “If you’re going up against big companies, litigation is so expensive,” said Jacqueline Biner, WHEN’s chief executive and legal officer. The organization aims to alleviate this burden, allowing public-interest cases to compete with well-resourced corporate defendants.





