Inquest reveals Sheffield United let down Maddy Cusack and women’s team during transition to full-time status

An inquest into the death of Maddy Cusack revealed that Sheffield United failed to adequately support the women’s team during its transition to full-time status in the summer of 2023. Ian McCallum, the former general manager of the women’s team, stated that the club was ‘naive’ about the necessary preparations.

Sheffield United's Mismanagement of Women’s Football

During the inquest, which took place on September 20, 2023, McCallum expressed his frustration with the club's handling of the women’s team. He noted that the transition to full-time football was not managed effectively, stating, “the club let a number of people down.” This sentiment was echoed by lawyers representing the Cusack family, who emphasized that the players deserved better support.

McCallum's tenure as general manager lasted from February 2023 until the end of the 2022-23 season. He mentioned that the club's approach felt like a ‘box-ticking exercise,’ and it was clear that the necessary resources were not in place to ensure the success of the women’s team.

Concerns Raised About Coaching and Management

Further complicating the situation, coach Jonathan Morgan was criticized during the inquest for not raising concerns with HR regarding Cusack’s mental wellbeing. Morgan admitted to escalating issues to the club doctor instead of following proper HR protocols. This decision came under scrutiny as it appeared that the safeguarding measures for players were not adequately followed.

McCallum also highlighted that he never witnessed any mistreatment of Cusack by Morgan, stating, “I had never witnessed Morgan shout at Cusack, nor did I ever see him mistreat the midfielder.” However, the lack of communication regarding player welfare remains a significant concern.

Upcoming Testimonies and Ongoing Investigation

As the inquest continues, senior staff members from Sheffield United, including Carl Shieber and chief executive Stephen Bettis, are scheduled to provide their testimonies. Their insights will be crucial in understanding how the club plans to improve its support for the women’s team going forward.

The inquest into Cusack’s death is not only about accountability but also aims to address systemic issues within the club that have affected the wellbeing of its players. The court will continue to explore the circumstances surrounding the management of the women’s team and the impact it had on Cusack's life.